Presenting competitive quotes as leverage has proven to yield better pricing outcomes. Indicate to Black Duck that you have received lower quotes from their competitors for similar features and services. This gives you leverage to negotiate lower prices or additional value adds.
Challenge any proposed uplift by highlighting that your budget has not accounted for additional spend beyond current contract amounts. Suggest that since the agreement does not note an uplift and considering their desire for continued partnership, the uplift should be waived.
If Black Duck proposes a new pricing model that could lead to higher costs, emphasize that you expect to maintain existing pricing considering volume and service levels as part of your commitment to continuous business. Anchoring on the historical pricing allows you to negotiate more effectively.
Discuss the imperative to remove any auto-renewal clauses to maintain flexibility for future negotiations. This can help maintain leverage during renewals when budget assessments occur.
Offer to serve as a case study or reference for Black Duck in exchange for better terms or discounts, highlighting the value that your endorsement can provide to them.